Showing posts with label Replevy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Replevy. Show all posts

Sunday, October 17, 2021

Links & Auctions

- The Lilly Library has acquired the marvelous dictionary collection of Madeline Kripke.

- Paul Needham's Lyell Lectures continue, and are viewable here as they are delivered.

- The ABAA's Diversity Initiative is hosting a panel, "Everyone is Welcome Here: Building Better Relationships in Book Communities" on 26 October. 

- Over at Medieval Manuscripts Provenance, "Otto Ege's Armenian Lectionary Dated '1121.'"

- Heather Wolfe will be the Munby Fellow at Cambridge University Libraries for 2021–22, working on a project titled "Decoding early modern writing paper."

- On the Swann Galleries blog, Devon Eastland writes about Harvard librarian George Parker Winship.

- Carla Cevasco writes for the Collation on "Picturing Children's Food in Early Modern Europe."

- There is still time to register for the APHA conference on 22–23 October, "Impresos: Printing Across Latin American and Caribbean Cultures."

- The bat signal has gone out for a number of Mark Twain legal documents which are believed to have been acquired by the Detroit Public Library in 1966 but were not found when a researcher looked for them in 2010. Barbara Schmidt has a feature on this over on Twain Quotes.

- A First Circuit panel has ruled that a 1780 Alexander Hamilton letter to Lafayette is the clear property of the Massachusetts Archives, and the letter has now been returned. It was stolen by employee Harold Perry sometime between 1938 and 1946 and later sold. Read the full decision here.

Upcoming Auctions

- The Luzzatto High Holidays Mahzor: A Magnificent Ashkenazic Prayer Book at Sotheby's New York on 19 October.

- Travel including a single owner collection of books on mountaineering at Bloomsbury Auctions (Dreweatts) ends on 20 October.

- A third selection of 16th and 17th English Books from the Fox Pointe Manor Library at Forum Auctions on 21 October.

- Fine Literature – Bukowski, Beats & the Counterculture at PBA Galleries on 21 October.

- Literature, Social Activism, Counterculture at Second Story Books on 23 October.

Sunday, March 01, 2020

Links & Auctions

- Rare Book Week New York is here!

- The group of Romanian nationals charged with the theft of rare books from a shipping warehouse near Heathrow at the end of January 2017 went on trial this week. Quite a lot more detail than I'd previously seen about the machinations ...

- Federal and state prosecutors were in court this week urging the return of a 1780 Alexander Hamilton letter (to Lafayette) to the Massachusetts State Archives. It is believed to have been among the items stolen by a library cataloger between 1938 and 1946, but is not specifically listed among the known stolen items when a list was released in 1950. It turned up after it was consigned to a Virginia auction house in 2018.

- Jennifer Schuessler writes for the NYTimes about recently-unveiled plans for a merger of the Brooklyn Historical Society and the Brooklyn Public Library.

- Don't miss Heather O'Donnell's tweet thread about a really fascinating manuscript she acquired last year.

- From the library of the Peterhouse Perne and Ward Libraries, "Independence Day," largely about the long-ago thefts from the libraries by Mark Fitzgeorge-Parker.

- Rare Book Monthly's March articles are available today.

- A 19th-century manuscript of Inca history stolen from the National Library of Peru during the Chilean occupation of Lima in the 1880s has been returned.

- TheBookGuide will cease publication at the end of March.

Upcoming Auctions

- Printed Books, Maps & Documents, Books from the Library of Dawson Turner, and the John Lawson Reference Library at Dominic Winter Auctioneers on 4 March.

- Rare Books at Heritage Auctions on 4 March.

- Maps and Atlases at Forum Auctions (online) on 5 March.

- Rare Photography: Books & Images – The Robert Enteen Collection. With Illustration & Fine Books at PBA Galleries on 5 March.

- Fine Books and Manuscripts at Bonhams New York on 6 March.

Sunday, January 17, 2016

Links & Reviews

- The New-York Historical Society's institutional archives are being processed, and a partial finding guide is now available.

- A York County, PA court of common pleas ledger from the 1820s was listed for sale on eBay recently: the York Dispatch has a report on the county's attempt to get the ledger back.

- Anchi Hoh writes for the Library of Congress blog about the recent acquisition of an important 15th-century Arabic manuscript on astronomy and mathematics.

- A rare Ottoman atlas from 1803 has been identified in the collections of the National Library of Norway.

- Caroline Duroselle-Melish covers the Folger's acquisitions of printed material and bindings from the Pirie sale for The Collation.

Reviews

- Josh Spero's Second-Hand Stories; review by Nicholas Lezard in the New Statesman.

- Nile Green's The Love of Strangers; review by Anita Anand in the NYTimes.

- Andrea Wulf's The Invention of Nature; review by Eric Herschthal in the CSM.

- Elizabeth Norton's The Temptation of Elizabeth Tudor; review by Steve Donoghue in the CSM.

- Marta Weiss' Julia Margaret Cameron (catalog to accompany a current V&A exhibit); review by Dinah Birch in the TLS.

- Rebecca Rego Barry's Rare Books Uncovered; reviews by Richard Davies at AbeBooks' Reading Copy, Amy Henderson in the Weekly Standard, and Jenna Lifhits in the Washington Free Beacon.

Sunday, June 02, 2013

Links & Reviews

Apologies for the rather lengthy post this week: I've been on the road just a bit (New York last weekend for some family time, then to Boston for a couple days, then to New York for Book Expo America (on which there is a good writeup in the NYTimes), and now in Charlottesville to kick off the Rare Book School season) so I've fallen quite behind and had accumulated lots of things to pass along. So here they all are!

- The Law Society of England and Wales is moving ahead with the sale of selected items from the Mendham Collection, which will occur (barring any last-minute action) on 5 June at Sotheby's (see the catalog). This has sparked quite a discussion about the legal, moral, and ethical implications of the Society's decision, including calls for a boycott of the sale. Watch this space for more on this as events progress this week.

- A volunteer at the Buffalo History Museum, Daniel J. Witek, 50, has been charged with the theft of letters and postcards from the Aaron Conger Goodyear collection. Witek, using the alias "Walter Payne," tried to sell the documents to Lion Heart Autographs of New York City, but Lion Heart president David Lowenherz contacted the museum. As a volunteer, BHM officials say, Witek used the name "Daniel Mountbatten-Witek." So far mail fraud is the only charge filed against Witek, but more to come on this one, I'm sure.

- The head of Library and Archives Canada resigned in mid-May over improper use of government funds, and the Canadian Association of Research Libraries has called on the prime minister to consult with the library and archives community about filling the vacancy.

- The Baltimore Sun reported this week on the gradual return of the documents stolen from various archives by Barry Landau and his accomplice. So far only about twenty percent of the recovered materials have been returned.

- Quite an interesting resolution to a longstanding standoff over one of the original copies of the Bill of Rights: the New York Public Library and the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania have agreed to share custody of the document for the next hundred years, at which time the settlement will be reexamined. The copy may be that which originally was sent to Pennsylvania (this is unclear); it has been at NYPL since 1896.

- Over on the Cardiff University rare books blog, a guide to manicules found in their collections.

- From Sarah Werner at The Collation: an excellent look at oddities in digital surrogates (and other topics).

- There's a good report on the PEN charity auction in the Telegraph; this saw a first edition of Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone annotated by J.K. Rowling sell for a record £150,000.

- Molly Schwartzburg posted a very interesting account of 18th-19th century cicada emergences as documented in 1824 by "J.S."

- The NYRB looks back on fifty years of book advertisements in its pages. At BEA this week I picked up a copy of the facsimile edition of the first NYRB issue they'd printed up for the anniversary, which makes for a very neat browse.

- Stephen Brumwell has been awarded the 2013 George Washington Book Prize for his forthcoming book George Washington: First Warrior.

- Two men have been sentenced in Denmark for the theft of more than 1,000 World War II documents from the Danish National Archives between 2009 and this year. The pair received jail terms of 24 and 21 months. Some documents were reportedly sold before they could be recovered.

- The great printer/designer Kim Merker died on 28 April; an obituary ran in the New York Times this week.

- From the new Mapping Books blog (link added on the sidebar), Mitch Fraas explores from a wide-angle view some of the things he's found in examining the "unique at Penn" ESTC books, and takes a look at the geographical distribution of the first edition of Whitman's Leaves of Grass.

- Vince Golden writes on the AAS blog about the recent acquisition of a volume of the National Magazine, purchased in honor of Marcus McCorison.

- The June AE Monthly is up; it includes an interview with Joel Silver, the new director of the Lilly Library.

- At the Public Domain Review, Christine Jones explores the early English translations of Charles Perrault's fairy tales.

- Heather Cole offered up a post on the anthropodermic binding at Houghton Library.

- John Van Horne, director of the Library Company of Philadelphia, has announced that he will retire in May 2014.

- From Erin Blake, the first in a series of posts about proof prints, covering trial proofs and progress proofs.

- Speaking at the Hay Festival of Literature, Matthew Haley of Bonhams told his audience that the loss of secondhand bookshops is a dangerous trend, but that "book towns" stand a real chance of successfully navigating the current rough waters.

- Jerry Morris at My Sentimental Library has posted some images and thoughts on the possibility that a book in his library may have belonged to John Hancock. We've emailed extensively about this and frankly I'm just not sure, but it makes for quite a good mystery!

- Also retiring is the chief librarian of the D.C. library system, Ginnie Cooper, profiled recently in the Washington Post.

- In a 1895 letter, Rudyard Kipling writes to an unknown correspondent that he may have "helped himself promiscuously" in drawing from other sources when he penned The Jungle Book.

- On the Houghton Library blog, a wonderful example of how collaborative scholarship is making some great things happen these days.

- The Junto folks have launched a podcast.

- From Nathan Raab at Forbes, a (very) brief survey of the history of the written word.

- The oldest known complete Torah scroll has been identified in the library of the University of Bologna; the twelfth-century manuscript had previously been miscataloged as dating from the seventeenth century.

- From the University of Glasgow rare books blog, a look at the use of false title pages in a 1670 octavo edition of Spinoza. And in other Spinoza-news, some good old-fashioned bibliographical detective work has resulted in the identification of Spinoza's printer.

- The Spring 2013 Common-place is out, and as usual is well worth a thorough read.

- Newly updated from the Society of Early Americanists: recent publications of interest to the field.

- I had a chance to read through the summer issue of the Journal of the Early Republic, and recommend it highly. Most of the articles draw on the A New Nation Votes project (AAS and Tufts), which is also a great way to wile away some time, I should note.

- At JCB Books Speak, Kenneth Ward reports on a very exciting new acquisition of a variant edition of Vetancurt's Arte de la lengua Mexicana (1673). There are some lingering mysteries around these two editions, so go check out the post and see if you can help!

- From Goran Proot at The Collation, a look at all ten Folger copies of the 1640 edition of Shakespeare's Sonnets. Duplicates? I think not!

- Over on The Appendix blog, a guest post from Ox and Pigeon editor Jason Curran.

- The Antiques Trade Digest reported recently on a few cases of the U.K. National Archives taking action to keep public records from being sold at auction.

- Felicity Henderson has a post on the Royal Society's blog about the group's early collections of curiosities.

- The John Rylands Library's Centre for Heritage Imaging and Collection Care will be digitizing the extensive archival collection of the papers of John Henry Cardinal Newman. They've started a blog to chronicle the project.

- On the OUP blog, Robert McNamee writes on the "marginalization" of Alexander Pope, both as a Catholic and for his physical deformity, and Pat Rogers offers up an essay on Pope's wordplay and writing technique.

- There's a short writeup in the Washington Post by Ron Charles on recent goings-on there, including an exhibit hall renovation and a particularly important copy of Shakespeare's works currently on display.

- From Princeton: the manuscript and annotated galleys of The Great Gatsby have been digitized.

Reviews

- Victor S. Navasky's The Art of Controversy; review by Deborah Solomon in the NYTimes.

- Peter Carlson's Junius and Albert's Adventures in the Confederacy; review by Tony Horwitz in the WaPo.

- Allen Guelzo's Gettysburg; review by Thomas Donnelly in the WSJ.

- J.R.R. Tolkien's The Fall of Arthur; review by Elizabeth Hand in the LATimes.

- David Scott's Leviathan; review by Brendan Simms in the Telegraph.

- E.O. Wilson's Letters to a Young Scientist; review by Bill Streever in the NYTimes.

- Philip Gura's Truth's Ragged Edge; review by Michael Gorra in the WSJ.

- Charlie Lovett's The Bookman's Tale; review by Rebecca Rego Barry at Fine Books Blog.

- Khaled Hosseini's And the Mountains Echoed; review by Wendy Smith in the LATimes.

- Joel Harrington's The Faithful Executioner; review by Daniel Stashower in the WaPo.

Sunday, February 10, 2013

Links & Reviews

We got about 32 inches of snow here in Portland yesterday, and the snowbanks and drifts around the neighborhood are very impressive indeed. Thankfully the snow stayed fluffy and light, and though the wind gusts got pretty nasty for a few hours, the power stayed on, so it's been an enjoyable storm in this neck of the woods. Between bouts of shoveling and walking around to take pictures yesterday I got a another chunk of the book-reorganization accomplished, too.

- Unfortunately the storm proved particularly nasty for Longfellow Books downtown, where a burst pipe caused the sprinkler system to go off and led to widespread damage in the shop. They're closed until further notice. Stay tuned for ways to help as we get more information, or watch the shop's Facebook page.

-  From Public Domain Review, Martin Spevack introduces Isaac D'Israeli's Curiosities of Literature.

- Over at The Collation, part two of Erin Blake's series on myth-busting early modern book illustration, this time considering how many impressions one might get from an engraved copper plate.

- Jennifer Howard reported this week on upcoming appeals in the GSU e-reserves case, including concerns that the Department of Justice may get involved.

- Garrett Scott at Bibliophagist has a great post this week on how researching a particular book or pamphlet can often prove to add much to its value.

- Eugene Delacroix's "Liberty Leading the People" was damaged by a vandal this week at a museum in Lens, France. The woman who defaced the painting was detained and conservators indicated that the graffito could probably be "easily cleaned."

- From the Houghton blog, a look at some books from Herman Melville's library newly acquired for Harvard's collections.

- Maine State Archivist David Cheever is considering the pursuit of legal action against an auctioneer trying to sell what purports to be an original order for a military draft in Maine's 1st congressional district, signed in 1863 by Abraham Lincoln. More on this as events warrant.

- At The Appendix, an interview with author Adam Hochschild.

- Quite an amazing story of a publisher suing a librarian for saying negative things about the publisher's product. Jessamyn West as a full roundup of links and coverage. Another report in The Chronicle.

- In the TLS, Sarah Knight and Mary Ann Lund explore how the now-confirmed remains of Richard III compare to traditional literary and historical descriptions of the monarch.

- A new online exhibition from the Library Company of Philadelphia: Black Founders: The Free Black Community in the Early Republic.

- The British Library has purchased approximately 100 diaries and some 900 letters of Sir Alec Guinness.

Reviews

- The Forgotten Writings of Bram Stoker; review by Michael Dirda in the Washington Post.

- Ad Stijnman's Engraving and Etching, 1400-2000; review by Elizabeth Upper in Apollo.

Sunday, October 30, 2011

Links & Reviews

- From the Baltimore Sun, which continues to do a very decent job covering the Landau library thefts, a profile of NARA's Art Recovery Team and its inspector general, Paul Brachfeld.

- Ron Charles weighs in on this week's discussion of "Anonymous" the so-called (and idiotic) "authorship controversy" with a great essay in the Washington Post.

- Laura Massey has a great post about how early debates over Shakespeare's authorship (and the belief that Francis Bacon had hidden ciphered messages in the printed plays) led to the rise of modern cryptography.

- Over at Anchora, Adam Hooks has started a series on Shakespeare fakes with a look at the various editions (pirated, faked, forged) of Shakespeare's poems.

- The "Bright Young Things" series on the Fine Books Blog continues with an interview of the duo behind B&B Rare Books.

- A collection being called the "last great private library in New Zealand" (that of naturalist Arthur Pycroft, who died in 1971) will be sold at auction this week.

- From Nick at Mercurius Politicus, a fascinating meditation on the material aspects of signatures.

- A volume of Stafford County, VA court records for the years 1749-1755 has been voluntarily returned to Virginia by the Jersey City Free Public Library, where the book was recently found. It had been taken during the Civil War by a Union soldier. The volume's contents will be made available for researchers at the Library of Virginia.

- The ABAA Security blog has posted a list of a collection recently discovered to be stolen. If I get more information on the circumstances, I'll be sure to post.

- Anthony Horowitz, the author of the new Sherlock Holmes story The House of Silk (the first to be approved by the Conan Doyle estate) writes in the Telegraph about the enduring Holmes legacy, and about his experiences in writing a Holmes mystery.

Reviews

- Richard Brookhiser's James Madison; reviews by Richard Beeman in the NYTimes and Jack Rakove in TNR.

- Denise Gigante's The Keats Brothers; review by Lesley McDowell in the Independent.

- Claire Tomalin's Charles Dickens: A Life and Robert Douglas-Fairhurst's Becoming Dickens; review by Frances Wilson in the Telegraph.

- David Bellos' Is That a Fish in Your Ear?; review by Adam Thirlwell in the NYTimes.

- Tony Horwitz's Midnight Rising; review by Kevin Boyle in the NYTimes.

Sunday, July 31, 2011

Belated Links & Reviews

Apologies for the radio silence this week; all my energies were devoted to my Rare Book School class, which was very useful and great fun. If you ever get a chance to take one of Heather Wolfe's paleography classes or seminars, do it. She's a fantastic teacher, and did a really amazing job with the class. We learned a great deal, and were able to get in some very good practice on both reading and even writing in secretary hand. I'll need to keep practicing, but thankfully the resource list Heather provided (along with a few of my own little projects) will keep me well supplied with materials to transcribe!

Being in Charlottesville this summer and seeing once again all the work, love, and energy that goes into making Rare Book School the incomparable place that it is was an amazing experience. It's a privilege and an honor to be able to assist in making it all come together! Now that the summer sessions are over, I'm looking forward to spending some time in my new city now, and getting back to all the projects I haven't done much with since early June. Oh, and my books still want organizing on the shelves, too ...

First, though, some links and reviews from this week. I apologize if I missed any good links that people sent around on Twitter; several days this week I had to declare Twitter-amnesty since there simply wasn't time to catch up with it all.

- The July Common-place is now out, with a good selection of articles as always.

- As expected, more shoes have begun to drop in the Barry Landau documents theft case, with evidence suggesting that he may have also taken documents from the National Archives, Connecticut Historical Society, and Vassar College, and that his accomplice may have flushed documents down the toilet before being arrested at the Maryland Historical Society.

- From Echoes from the Vault, a new acquisition of a rare Esther Inglis miniscule manuscript is highlighted.

- The Deseret News reports on a cassette tape of Mark Hofmann selling one of his forgeries that has now been made public for the first time.

- The Tennessee state court of appeals has rejected Margaret Vance Smith's claim to Davy Crockett's marriage license, holding that there is no evidence that Knox County officials ever intended to discard the document.

Reviews

- James Grant's Mr. Speaker!; review by Norman Ornstein in the NYTimes.

- Anthony Amore and Tom Mashberg's Stealing Rembrandts; review by Chuck Leddy in the Boston Globe.

- Richard Mabey's Weeds; review by Elizabeth Royte in the NYTimes.

- The new University of Nebraska edition of Audubon's 1826 journal; review by Anthony Doerr in the Boston Globe.

Sunday, May 09, 2010

Links & Reviews

- There's a new blog on the block, courtesy of Laura at bookn3rd - The Cataloguer's Desk, which Laura and other staff at Peter Harrington will be contributing to. Their first post, on William Moon's letter system for the blind, is delightful. They've also begun a Twitter feed. I've added a link on the sidebar to the blog, and subscribed to the feeds.

- In the Globe today, a Q&A with BPL president Amy Ryan.

- Book Patrol notes that Salem OR's Tea Party Bookshop will be changing its name, after many misunderstandings.

- Paul Collins, reprising a theme, comments on the news that Verizon wants to do away with white page phone books in NYC.

- Environmental writer Roger Deakin's archive will go to the University of East Anglia, the Guardian reports.

- A new watermarks site is up.

- About 200 rare books were damaged at Knoxville's Calvin M. McClung Historical Collection this week when the air conditioner malfunctioned. The books have been frozen and will be conserved by Don Etherington in NC.

- A collection of 700+ Edward Gorey items has been donated to Columbia by architectural historian Andrew Alpern.

- Writing in the NYTimes, Michael Kimmelman makes the case that Britain should keep the Elgin Marbles.

Reviews

- Daisy Hay's Young Romantics: review by Miranda Seymour in the Telegraph.

- Marla Miller's Betsy Ross and the Making of America: review by Laurel Thacher Ulrich in the NYTimes.

- Nick Bunker's Making Haste to Babylon: review by John Demos in the WaPo.

Monday, May 25, 2009

Links & Reviews

Back from my trip, and now have some links and things to pass along:

- There is some updated information on the state of things in Cologne, where the municipal archives building collapsed on 3 March. It seems that a "substantial part" of the records have been recovered through various emergency conservation measures.

- The Avicenna text stolen from a museum in Hamadan, Iran, has been recovered on Sunday. "No details about the robbery or the perpetrators was released."

- Finally reading the writing on the wall (as Tim notes), OCLC has officially withdrawn their proposed records use policy.

- Word last week that Google has capitulated and will allow "some libraries a degree of oversight over the prices Google could charge for its vast digital library ... Only the institutions that lend books to Google for scanning - now 21 libraries in the United States - would be allowed to object to pricing." The ALA says this doesn't go far enough, arguing that any library should be able to protest the fees.

- A fascinating story from England, where a marine chronometer assigned to HMS Erebus, one of the ill-fated ships sent to the far north of Canada with Sir John Franklin (the other was HMS Terror), has been discovered. The chronometer somehow made its way back to Britain, but horologists and officials at the National Maritime Museum are at a complete loss to explain how.

- Travis McDade is back, with an excellent article in Maine Antique Digest about the Augsburger Geschlechterbuch, which a federal judge recently ruled should be returned to Germany. It has been in the U.S. since the end of WWII.

Reviews

- Iain Pears' Stone's Fall is reviewed by Jack Kerridge in the Telegraph.

- In the Boston Globe, Michael Kenney reviews John Ross' War on the Run, a look at Robert Rogers' military career.

Saturday, February 28, 2009

More Coverage of Declaration Decision

A sampling of today's media coverage of the Virginia Supreme Court's decision yesterday in the case of the Wiscasset Declaration:

- The Richmond Times-Dispatch report has further quotes from Maine archivist David Cheever: "We are very disappointed. I'm just sorry they reached the decision they did. It seems like a bit of a stretch, but we waged a good fight, they prevailed." He said he did not believe the town would seek to buy back the broadside: "To buy it back when it's something that we think belongs in the public realm anyway would be a decision that Wiscasset might make, but one I would not recommend. I would be more apt to encourage Mr. Adams to donate it back to the town."

- A Washington Post piece by Fredrick Kunkle features the first reaction from the attorney for Richard Adams, whose claim to the Declaration is now quieted: "
We're very pleased with the ruling. It's what we hoped." And more from Cheever, who said that this decision "only inflames a sense in Maine that too much of its history has been raided by out-of-state collectors. 'Here's somebody from 'away' who comes in and finds something of value,' Cheever said. 'Because it's the Declaration of Independence, the hair on the back of the neck stands up. This shouldn't be leaving.'"

- And in the Portland Press-Herald report, assistant state attorney general Thomas Knowlton: "We are extremely disappointed in the decision, we strongly disagree with the court's interpretation of the law and its application of the law to these facts."

Friday, February 27, 2009

VA Supreme Court Rules for Collector in Declaration Case

As expected, the Virginia Supreme Court ruled today that collector Richard Adams, Jr. can keep his copy of a 1776 Declaration of Independence broadside (Salem: E. Russell) claimed by the state of Maine. I've posted background on the case here, and the most recent news we had was from when the case was argued before the state Supreme Court back in January.

In a 19-page ruling [PDF], the court upheld a trial court's February 2008 decision that Maine had no right to the document, since the state had failed to prove that the Declaration had ever officially been a town record.

Maine's state archivist, David Cheever, said he found the court's ruling "incredible," adding "To us, it's a public document. It was then. It is now. ... The unfortunate result is a public record that we believe rightfully belongs to the people of Maine is now in the hands of a private collector in Virginia."

Adams' attorney successfully argued that the town clerk's copy of the Declaration made in the town record books serves as the "official" record, since the Massachusetts Executive Council's order accompanying the Declaration "directed the town clerks to record the Declaration’s text in their respective town record books 'to remain as a perpetual Memorial thereof.' Neither the Executive Council’s order nor any other law directed the town clerks regarding the proper disposition of the broadsides after their contents were transcribed in the town record books."

The supreme court agreed with the trial court that the broadside "did not meet the common law definition of a 'public record' because a public officer did not create the print." They write: "The fact that the Executive Council authorized Russell to print the broadsides did not transform his employment status from that of a private printer to one of a public officer. Russell was not executing the duties of public office at the time he printed the broadsides. ... the duty of the town’s clerk to create a public record of the Declaration emanated from the Executive Council’s order directing that the clerks of the various towns record the text of the Declaration in their town books 'there to remain as a perpetual Memorial thereof.' This order of the Executive Council reflected the importance of the clerks’ acts of transcription and the fact that the written entries they created were to be the perpetual record of the Declaration in the various town books."

Finally, the court refuses to examine the question of whether the fact that the Declaration was found in the home of a former town clerk means that it was unlawfully removed from the town's possession (and thus could be returned even if it wasn't a 'public record').

So that's it for this case. There is no further appeal.

Sunday, February 01, 2009

Links & Reviews

- In the Globe this morning, a rundown of the dire straits faced by Boston-based publisher Houghton Mifflin Harcourt as textbook sales plummet.

- Ed's got the latest roundup of Poe War coverage, and notes that he'll be appearing on 3 February at Lehigh University to read "The Raven" alongside Lehigh's elephant folio version of Audubon's raven.

- Today's Raymond Scott news: he tells The Sun that he may follow Oscar Wilde's example when he goes to court this month and stay completely silent: "Maybe on this occasion I will learn a lesson from history. I have absolutely nothing to hide. I know I am entirely innocent of both charges. But much though I’d like the chance to protest my innocence, I might just stay silent." Somehow I don't see that happening.

- An update to the Pennsylvania replevin case first reported here back in October: state court judge Dan Pellegrini has ruled that the dispute, between antiques dealer Edward Marshall and the Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission, must go to trial. Both parties had requested an immediate ruling from the judge, but Pellegrini said that the state must prove its claim (that a prison record book now owned by Marshall was stolen).

- Via Joyce and others, news that Chronicle Books will be releasing Pride and Prejudice and Zombies, a "re-telling" of Jane Austen's story by Seth Grahame-Smith.

- From BibliOdyssey, eclipse images from Cyprian Leowitz's Eclipses luminarium summa fide et accurata diligentia supputatae, ac figuris coloribusque suis artificiose depictae, quarum rationes ab anno domini 1554. usque in annum domini 1600. se extendunt et ad meridianum Viennae Austriae referuntur ("Accurate coloured depictions of solar and lunar eclipses covering the years 1554 to 1600 with Vienna, Austria as the point of reference").

- Forbes profiles Arthur Schwarz, whose collection of materials related to Henry VIII will go on exhibit at the Grolier Club in March as "Vivat Rex! Commemorating the 500th Anniversary of the Accession of Henry VIII." The show will run at the Grolier Club until May, and will be displayed at the Folger Library next year. [Edited to add: as Mr. Schwarz mentions in comments, many of the items in the exhibit are from the "collections of the Folger, Houghton, and Morgan Libraries, plus five additional lenders."]

- Tim rolled out some new LT features this week, including the ability to add books via Twitter, and a new "Dead or Alive" meme, which prompted a marked upswing (to put it mildly) of Common Knowledge contributions.

- At PBS' Mediashift, Bryan Murley writes on how the economic downturn has begun to affect college newspapers. [h/t]

- MIT recently received 37 prints from Audubon's Quadrupeds, and they're on display through through 19 February in MIT's Maihaugen Gallery.

- Mike Widener writes on the Yale Law Library blog about the "rest of the story" behind an 1830 edition of Blackstone the library received by donation last fall.

- Paul Collins found a very amusing trick bass viol lurking among the patent files.

- Patricia Cohen writes in today's NYTimes on a growing brouhaha over the transcripts of Nixon tapes as published in Stanley Kutler's 1997 book Abuse of Power: The New Nixon Tapes. A group of authors and historians led by Peter Klingman have submitted a paper to the American Historical Review charging that Kutler selectively edited the transcriptions to indicate a more-benevolent-then-warranted role for John Dean. Kutler says that any mistakes made were accidental.

Reviews

- In the Boston Globe, Richard Eder reviews Marjorie Garber's Shakespeare and Modern Culture, which he describes as "not preaching so much as pirouetting to the academic choir."

- Desmond and Moore's Darwin's Sacred Cause and Adam Gopnik's Angels and Ages are reviewed by Christopher Benfey in the NYTimes.

- Michael Dirda reviews Kitty Burns Florey's Script and Scribble in the WaPo.

- Leah Price reviews the two new Samuel Johnson bios (by Martin and Meyers) for the NYTimes. She concludes: "Johnson said of Paradise Lost that 'none ever wished it longer,' and the same could be said of both biographies."

- Marilyn Stasio reviews Lepore and Kamensky's Blindspot in the NYTimes. She liked it rather more than I did.

Wednesday, January 14, 2009

VA Supreme Court Hears Declaration Arguments

Yesterday's arguments before the Supreme Court of Virginia regarding the Wiscasset Declaration of Independence went off as scheduled, the Times-Dispatch reports. Maine's assistant attorney general argued that "Public documents belong to the government, they don't belong to people," maintaining that the 1776 Salem imprint of the Declaration should be returned to the town of Wiscasset (which in 1776 was Pownalborough, MA). Attorneys for Richard Adams, the collector who now owns the document, argued that since there is no evidence that the Declaration was in town custody from 1776 through 1994 (when it was found in the attic of a former town clerk's family home), the state has no grounds to claim it.

Adams' lawyers argued yesterday that the copy of the Declaration hand-copied into the town's record books by then-clerk became the official copy of record, and that since there is nothing to indicate what town officials wanted done with the printed copy, the broadside's title is clear. Thomas Knowlton, Maine's lawyer, "
told the justices that to prove it is a public town record, Maine need only show that Russell, a private printer, was acting in an official capacity when he printed the copies and that the town had possession of it for as little as one day."

The Supreme Court of Virginia is the court of last resort for Maine, which cannot appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court since there is no federal issue at stake in the case. A ruling is expected before the end of February.

Sunday, October 12, 2008

Links & Reviews

- The Boston Globe has a profile of Jeff Mayersohn, the new owner of Harvard Bookstore.

- Emory University has acquired the papers of journalist and biography Marshall Frady, purchasing the archive for $10,000 (a price called "ridiculously low" by Emory's library director). The papers went to auction after being seized from Frady's widow by the IRS. The only other bidder was Frady's alma mater, Furman University.

- This week's issue of The Onion (a reprint of their issue from 6 October 1783), is very amusing. [h/t Steamboats]

- BibliOdyssey has images of alchemical laboratories.

- Back in March I noted an effort to get Moby-Dick declared the "official book" of Massachusetts, which I thought then was a little ridiculous. Well, of course the legislature doesn't have anything better to do, so they've continued to discuss the issue. On Thursday the state House passed a bill that would make the novel the state's official "epic novel," rather than "official book," after objections were raised by legislators from Salem and Concord. The representative from Concord, in fact, said of the Moby-Dick plan "I am appalled! What about Louisa May Alcott? What about Hawthorne? How am I going to face my constituents?" Alright guys, now get back to work.

- From the Poe Wars: Ed commented this week on Poe's death-day (7 October) and on a new bicentennial Poe exhibit at the Philadelphia Free Library.

- Laura has started her book history courses, and offers a web-tutorial on imposition.

- The Unshelved folks have some new "Library" gear.

- Various parties involved with the potential sale of rare books from the Cardiff library system have found "a way forward," the BBC reports. Representatives from the "Cardiff council, Cardiff University, the National Library of Wales and Glamorgan Record Office" had what is being described as a "positive meeting" this week and said in a joint statement that they had "agreed that they would work together to identify which items from the collection should be recommended to be retained in Wales." More discussions are planned.

- Sarah Vowell was on NPR this week to discuss The Wordy Shipmates.

- In the October/November Policy Review, Peter Berkowitz comments on the contemporary relevance of Thomas Hobbes' Leviathan. [h/t Cliopatria]

- Paul Collins notes his New Scientist article on octagonal houses.

- Everett Wilkie sent word to the Ex-Libris list of a rather remarkable replevin case in Pennsylvania, where the state has seized a volume of Eastern State Penitentiary prison records (covering the period 1839-1850) from book dealer Edward Marshall. Marshall had purchased the volume from Freeman's auction house in 1999, beating out bidders from the Penitentiary (which closed in 1970 but is now operated as a historic site). Staff there say that the earlier and later record books are in the collections of the state archives, and that Marshall's volume, having once belonged to the state, remains a state record. Marshall maintains that the book should not have been seized without a warrant and that there is no evidence that it was stolen. I'll keep an eye on this one, since it could make for a very interesting case.

- Ian offers up some good book curses, and he's also got some dispatches from the Seattle Book Fair.

- Melanie Battoe, the director of the Guernsey Memorial Library in Norwich, NY (who found herself in some serious hot water this summer after a state audit revealed more than $15,000 worth of improper purchases with library funds) has resigned. Battoe's resignation will take effect 30 November, until which time Battoe will remain on paid administrative leave.

Reviews

- Simon Schama has another book out. The American Future: A History is reviewed by Raymond Seitz for The Telegraph. The book accompanies Schama's new BBC series about America, and Seitz sees the book more of a performance piece than series history: "One glides through this book because Schama undeniably writes with colour and verve, but he also leaves the impression that he wishes to be the Pavarotti of historians, when in fact he seems more like the Barry Manilow ('You don't love me half as much as I do'). There is some excellent history here, but it struggles to escape from the stylistic vanity."

- Evelyn Lord's The Hell-Fire Clubs: Sex, Satanism and Secret Societies is reviewed by Malcolm Gaskill for The Telegraph and in an uncredited short review for The Scotsman.

- For The Telegraph, Jonathan Keates reviews Tim Birkhead's The Wisdom of Birds, a history of British ornithology and birding.

- John Demos' The Enemy Within is reviewed by Germaine Greer in the NYTimes. She's not a fan.

- Marc Lambert reviews Richard Holmes' The Age of Wonder for The Scotsman. Holmes also talks to Guy Dammann for The Guardian Online.

- The Economist contains an unsigned review of Timothy Ryback's Hitler's Private Library.

Tuesday, March 25, 2008

NC Wins its Bill of Rights

A five-year legal battle over North Carolina's copy of the Bill of Rights ended yesterday when a judge ruled that the document officially belongs to the state.

Manuscript copies of the Bill of Rights were dispatched to each state during the ratification process in 1789. North Carolina's was snatched by a Union soldier during the Civil War and made its way to Ohio, then to Indiana before disappearing for years. In 2000, Connecticut antiques dealer Wayne Pratt and real estate broker Robert Matthews bought the document; they tried to sell it to the National Constitution Center in 2003; a federal judge ordered the Bill of Rights seized instead. In 2005 the document was returned to North Carolina, but legal chaos continued until it was brought to a halt yesterday by Superior Court Judge Henry Hight's ruling.

News reports from the Asheville Citizen-Times, WRAL, and the News & Observer.

For background on the case, see this article from the 8 August 2005 Christian Science Monitor, and their earlier piece on the 2003 sting operation.

Wednesday, March 05, 2008

Maine to Appeal Declaration Decision

I thought I'd look this morning and see if there were any updates on a case I posted about back in early December: the state of Maine had sued a Virginia man in an attempt to force the return of a 1776 printing of the Declaration of Independence (all the backstory is here). The trial in Fairfax County was set for 15 January, but I hadn't - until this morning - been able to find any discussion of what happened.

Portland's WMTW reports today that the Virginia judge ruled last month in favor of Richard L. Adams, Jr., the current owner of the Declaration, but that Maine officials have decided to appeal the ruling. I haven't yet been able to figure out how to pull up the case in the Virginia court system database so I don't have any further information than that just yet - but as soon as I can find anything, I'll post more.

[Update: Still don't have the text, but Everett Wilkie found another news piece about the case in the 28 February issue of the Wiscasset Newspaper.

Long excerpt: "Several factors hurt Maine's case. One was the testimony from Maine's own expert witness, Albert H. Whitaker, Jr. who said the 'broadsides were not typically kept.' The court found that Maine had not proved its public record statute applied in this case, and even if it did, the statute defines public records as 'received and maintained' by a municipality. 'Whether the Pownalborough Print was 'maintained' by Pownalborough or Wiscasset has not been conclusively established here,' the court said.

"Maine tried to prove that the print was kept by the town clerk because of the manner in which it was folded, the 'docketing' on the back of the print, and the fact that Sol Holbrook was the town clerk and the print was found in his daughter's attic. Specialists in colonial era documents from Sotheby's testified that they had seen between 80 and 100 broadsides of the Declaration of Independence, and that all of them were folded because of the odd size of the paper, but not necessarily because they were kept by town clerks. Another expert witness testified that 'anyone could have made the docketing entries, and that one docketing struck him as incorrect because it identified it as a 'warrant,' when in fact, it was not a warrant.'

"Maine argued that because the Pownalborough Print was not one of the many town documents recorded in the town book, 'it must have been wrongfully removed.'

"But the court found that such records of documents - 'an index, in effect of what was retained - were presumably passed from clerk to clerk. Any clerk doing an inventory of the town records would have known which records were missing by looking at the town book. If the original print was to be retained as an official town record, then, at some point, some clerk receiving the book without also receiving the broadside would have realized that it was missing. Yet, Maine presented no evidence that any town clerk ever realized the Pownalborough Print was not among the town records, and, as a result, sought it out. The print was never believed 'missing' until Maine learned of its sale.'

"Maine tried to prove ownership because it was found in the attic of town clerk Sol Holbrook's daughter. However, the court said since Sol Holbrook never lived in the house where the print was found, there was no evidence this was true.

"And, even if Sol Holbrook had once had it in his possession, the court said, 'It still begs the ultimate question… whether Sol Holbrook gave to someone a town record as opposed to a discarded broadside.'"

Without having read the full text, the ruling actually seems quite fair to me. I'll be interested to see what grounds Maine chooses to appeal on.]

[Further update: A colleague's forwarded me another local newspaper story, this one from the Lincoln County News. Another very interesting bit from the court's ruling: "The State of Maine introduced no evidence that any applicable statute in effect in 1776 required a state or town to retain broadsides generally or the Pownalborough print specifically. In fact, the Order printed on the Pownalborough print only requires it be read by the ministers of each parish and then delivered to the town clerks so that the clerks could record the words into the town books." Such a recording was made 10 November, 1776.

"The court reasoned under Virginia law, Maine as the party not possessing the copy had to bear the burden of proof that the print was 'converted' from its rightful owner." Maine's claims failed to meet this burden, the court ruled.]

Sunday, February 10, 2008

Links & Reviews

- A blog-birth announcement: Special Collections Research Center, written by the SCRC staff at the University of Chicago. Very interesting posts so far. I've put up a sidebar link and added the blog's feed to my Google Reader.

- The town of Dover, NH is set to receive three volumes of its early town records after they were nearly sold at auction in Texas last week, the Foster's Daily Democrat reports. After the town learned of the impending sale and called the auction house, the records' consignor agreed to donate the volumes to the town (rather than face a lawsuit that might have forced their return). [h/t Everett Wilkie]

- From BibliOdyssey this week, engravings from Mausoleum Potentissimorum ac Gloriosissimorum Regni Apostolici Regum et Primorum Militantis Ungariae Ducum' (Mausoleum of the Most Powerful Kings and Dukes of Hungary) by Ferenc Nádasdy, 1664; also a "geomancy almanac" from the 1550s, described as "a combination of astrological/astronomical treatise, religious almanac and prediction calendar."

- The George Washington University Law School's Jacob Burns Law Library has acquired French law book collection of the Association of the Bar of the City of New York, comprising some 600 volumes of French legal texts from the 16th-19th centuries.

- The University of Iowa Special Collections has unveiled the Atlas of Early Printing, "
an online, interactive map depicting the early years of printing in the fifteenth century and the spread of the new technology across Europe." The site may require a FlashPlayer update.

- Ed has another dispatch from his recent visit to Philly, where he witnessed the arrival of the Poe Toaster.

- In the Harvard Magazine, Cambridge booksellers James and Devon Gray are profiled. [h/t John Overholt]

- The University of South Carolina's Thomas Cooper Library has opened an exhibition of medieval manuscripts: "
Pages from the Past: A Legacy of Medieval Books in South Carolina Collections." The catalog is available here.

- Jim Watts asks "Is there growing contempt for books?" I think his analysis here is spot-on.

- Over at Steamboats Are Ruining Everything, Caleb comments on a truly nefarious practice by publishers: selling print-on-demand copies of out-of-print backstock. "Inside hard covers deceptively similar to those of the other volumes, the publisher had stuck a text block that was only a shoddy knock-off of what ought to have been there. But, reader, they charged full price." Not cool.

- From the University of Seville, a huge list of digital books available through their website, so if you are in need of any Spanish antiquarian titles, do check here.

Reviews

- Richard Cox review and discusses Drew Gilpin Faust's This Republic of Suffering, noting that the book "provides considerable discussion about the creation of new kinds of public and private recordkeeping ... Although it is not Faust’s intent to write a meditation on the archival impulse, archivists and others interested in archives reading this book will come away with a deeper sense of why records are created and why they are preserved."

- In the LATimes, Art Winslow reviews Susan Jacoby's The Age of American Unreason.